In addition, the scholars note that meekness is another problem in Supreme Court decisions, such as how the Sedition Act, which criminalized criticizing the federal government, was upheld over and over. Hardwick, a 1986 case about anti-sodomy laws, called homosexuality a “crime against nature.” 18, 1944, the justices sustained the conviction. Fred Toyosaburo Korematsu, another young American citizen of unquestioned loyalty, had been convicted of failing to obey the removal order. WA Supreme Court’s worst decisions ever, according to its chief justice JWashington Supreme Court Chief Justice Steven González speaks during an interview in the Temple of Justice on the Capitol Campus in Olympia on June 1. According to Amar, one of the reasons the case made the list was because of its language, calling blacks “inferior.” Similarly, Bowers v. United States ( pdf) was one of the worse Supreme Court decisions ever issued. Next, the two examine the Dred Scott case, which declared blacks were nonpersons. Read about the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case. Wade decisions leap into a new area of law. Since the laws were passed in the nineteenth century, before women could vote, the laws should have been set aside and created by the legislature if the people so desired. Amar adds that a better decision would have been a narrow one that held Texas had anti-abortion laws that severely restricted women’s bodies and their liberty. It was beyond racism, totally devoid of humanity. Taney was atrocious coming from anyonelet alone a member of the Supreme Court. Wade decision should be in the list of the worst cases, because it was not based in the Constitution, it struck down state statutes, and created new law. The worst decision the Supreme Court ever made was Dred Scott in 1857, upholding the obnoxious Fugitive Slave Act. According to Amar, the Warren court almost never overruled acts of Congress, especially civil rights laws, which the Rehnquist court does frequently.

Last year a pregnant teenager crossed the border into Texas. Undocumented immigrants don’t have abortion rights. Lazarus argues that there are times when Congress oversteps and needs to be checked by the courts, but Amar responds with an analysis of the Rehnquist Court and the Warren Court. The Supreme Court, for reasons unclear, didn’t take up that question.

Worst supreme court decisions